Ruth Paul

Total 9 Posts

Ruth obtained her law degree from Queen’s University. Prior to law school, she completed her Bachelor of Arts (Honours) in Political Science from Western University. During her time at Queen’s University, Ruth volunteered with Queen’s Legal Aid Clinic, Pro Bono Students Canada, and the 519 Trans ID Clinic. She also competed in the 2024 Laskin Moot Court Competition in Calgary, Alberta and won second best factum.

Filling in the Gaps: Extrinsic Evidence and s. 21.1 of the SLRA

On June 15, 2024, Robert Chang (“Robert”) received an unexpected text from his brother, Luen-Wen Chang (the “Luen-Wen”). Luen-Wen advised Robert that he was ill and asked Robert to visit him as soon as possible. Luen-Wen also said he wanted to “give [his] will” to Robert. On June 19, 2024, Robert (who lived in Dallas, Texas) visited an Etobicoke Hospital and learned that Luen-Wen was terminally ill. During this visit,….

Filling in the Gaps: Extrinsic Evidence and s. 21.1 of the SLRA Continue Reading »

Wills

Relationships Matter: Revisiting Buffa v. Giacomelli

My colleagues, Diane Vieira and Karen Watters, Partners at de VRIES LITIGATION LLP, both wrote blogs on Buffa v. Giacomelli, 2025 ONSC 4024. Diane’s blog can be found here, and Karen’s blog can be found here. This matter was recently heard in the Court of Appeal in Buffa v. Giacomelli, 2026 ONCA 566. Background Alexander Buffa (“Alexander”) and Laura Giacomelli (“Laura”) were the children of Giuliana Buffa (“Giuliana” and the….

Relationships Matter: Revisiting Buffa v. Giacomelli Continue Reading »

Uncategorized

Wills Only in Electronic Form: s. 21.1 of the SLRA Does Not Apply

The decision in Samide v. Taylor, 2026 ONSC 3589 provides clarity on the interplay of the Succession Law Reform Act (“SLRA”) and the Electronic Commerce Act (“ECA”), specifically the applicability of these statutes on wills that only exist electronically. Robert Samide (“Robert”) died unexpectedly in July 2024. He was survived by his children: Jessica, Nicole and Christopher, as well as his domestic partner, Shantel Taylor (“Shantel”) and her three sons…..

Wills Only in Electronic Form: s. 21.1 of the SLRA Does Not Apply Continue Reading »

Uncategorized

Rogers v. Ferretti: Further Clarification on the Minimal Evidentiary Threshold

In a previous blog post, I discussed the importance of the minimal evidentiary threshold in will challenges. Notably, when document discovery is sought in a will challenge, the moving party must substantiate the release of a deceased person’s personal information, such as medical records and solicitors’ files. The minimal evidentiary threshold protects a deceased person’s privacy and deters disgruntled beneficiaries from commencing fishing expeditions into the deceased’s affairs simply because….

Rogers v. Ferretti: Further Clarification on the Minimal Evidentiary Threshold Continue Reading »

Uncategorized

Testamentary Capacity Does Not Require Perfection: Brockbank v Parkinson

Days before the February 2022 Russian invasion in Ukraine, Darcy Brockbank (“Darcy” or the “Estate”, respectively) travelled to Kiev. On February 25, 2022, Darcy died unexpectedly from a heart attack. He was survived by his mother, Josephine Brockbank (“Josephine”), and two brothers: Joel Brockbank (“Joel”) and Stuart Brockbank (“Stuart”). On May 24, 2023, Joel received a certificate of appointment of estate trustee without a will. Approximately one year later, the….

Testamentary Capacity Does Not Require Perfection: Brockbank v Parkinson Continue Reading »

Capacity Law, Contested wills, Testamentary Capacity

Saying It Doesn’t Make It So: Determining the Nature an Application

A notice of application marks the beginning of estate litigation proceedings. The notice of application provides an overview and outlines the precise relief sought, the grounds to be argued (including any statutory provisions or rules to be relied on) and the evidence to be relied on at the hearing of the application. As the grounds and relief sought in an application are often captured by numerous statutory authorities, a notice….

Saying It Doesn’t Make It So: Determining the Nature an Application Continue Reading »

Uncategorized
Scroll to Top