
Canada has strong charity laws and helpful administrative guidance. But strong laws alone don’t translate into good, efficient charity regulation. A modern regulator runs on workflows, dashboards, risk-based analysis, and data. By these measures, the Canada and its charity regulator, Canada Revenue Agency (CRA), trails its international peers.
The Federal Government is Consulting on Modernizing the Federal Framework for the Charitable Sector. The paper covers registration, digital services, audit and compliance, and revocation. The consultation paper focuses on administrative detail, and that’s encouraging. Digitalization and analysis are the foundation of efficient modern regulation.
Paper is the problem
Just under 31% of T3010 registered charity returns arrived electronically in 2025-26. Online filing has been available since June 2019, and it is still optional. Every paper return needs manual data entry before anyone can analyze it, so the data arrives late and unvalidated. In my experience, the Charities Directorate spends far more time and money on keying returns than on studying what they say. T3010 electronic filing needs to be mandatory.
Peers went digital. Canada made exceptions.
The United States requires e-filing of Forms 990 and publishes the data in machine-readable form. Australia collects its Annual Information Statement through an online portal and analyses the results. England and Wales run annual returns through an online service that updates a public register. Canada has been indulgent. Out of respect for small, rural and volunteer-run charities, it has allowed paper for years. That respect is well placed. The results are not.
Leniency has a cost
A regulator that cannot see its sector relies on blunt, ineffective tools. In 2025-26, the CRA completed 227 audits across 85,348 charities, about one for every 380. Those audits led to 52 revocations. That same year, 1,219 charities lost registration for failing to file, 23 times as many, and about 30% re-applied. That is churn, not good oversight. It consumes CRA staff and charity time and produces no meaningful outcome.
What the CRA should do
- Set a date. Legislate mandatory electronic T3010 filing, with a narrow, time-limited exemption process. The CRA’s 2027 aim should become a requirement.
- Validate at entry. Check arithmetic, pre-fill known information and reject incomplete returns.
- Help small charities. Offer a free CRA-hosted form and an assisted-digital pathway, so volunteers are not left behind.
- Build analytics. Set organization baselines by size, sector and region, flag anomalies and monitor continuously. Use dashboards, not filing cabinets.
- Automate escalation. Send a reminder, then a notice, a penalty and a suspension of receipting, with revocation as the last step.
- Publish the data. Release machine-readable sector data and aggregate results on audits, sanctions and revocations. Researchers, donors and journalists will add scrutiny at no cost.
Risk-based means data on everyone
Risk-based regulation only works when there is current data on every charity, including the compliant majority. Baselines show the regulator where the system works. They allow lighter treatment of low-risk charities and focus on higher-risk ones. Filing mistakes will be caught. AI can help screen filings and rank cases for review, if trained officials make the decisions, flags are explainable and charities keep the right to object. The charitable sector has long-standing long-standing concern about the paucity of charitable sector data. Data should be immediately available to charities, regulators, Statistics Canada, and researchers.
Not a new idea
The irony is CRA already has a full digital system for ordinary taxpayers. CRA now receives 94% of T1 returns electronically. Tax slips are automatically uploaded. Refunds are made within a week. Soon most employed taxpayers will no need to file a tax return. It’s not a perfect system, but digitization provides the opportunity for continuous improvement. CRA’s Charities Directorate knows this but has not received funding. Unfortunately, charity regulation is just not a priority in Ottawa.
Spend on outcomes, not data entry
In October 2026, the CRA issued workforce adjustment notices to 735 employees after the announcement of 15% budget cut. A smaller regulator cannot sustain manual processes. Budget pressure is a reason to automate, not to delay. Registered charities are volunteer-run and central to civil society. They deserve a regulator that is fast, transparent and data-driven. The CRA – back up by mandatory filing laws and funding – should set the date, build the system, and publish the results.
